A. V. Ashikhmin. The Administrative-Territorial Structure of Pre-Reform Russia: The Evolution
of Historiographical Concepts // Petersburg Historical Journal, no. 2, 2026, pp. 206–220.

DOI 10.51255/2311–603X_2026_2_206

Abstract:

Administrative and territorial changes have been a subject of considerable interest in historical
literature for over 150 years. Indeed, they constituted an integral part of state reforms during the 18th and the first half of the 19th centuries. Concurrenting with the evolution of historical conceptions concerning these transformations (notably the reforms initiated by Peter the Great and Catherine the Great), methodological frameworks employed for the study of the territorial configuration of the empire have undergone significant refinement. During the historical transformation of these issues, several significant models can be identified. They include the transition from historical and statistical methods in the late 18th and early 19th centuries to
positivist studies in the Imperial period, followed by a period of neglect of the topic in Soviet historiography. This was followed by a revival of interest and the return to historical and geographical studies. The recent post-Soviet interest in this area has resulted in the emergence of both new positivist works of high quality and works that challenge recent historiographic approaches, such as “new imperial history”, modernization theory and regionalism. The historical understanding of the role of administrative-territorial divisions in state reform in the Russian Empire represents a promising area for research, supported not only by recent publications but
also by the presence of specialised institutions both in the capital and in major cities across the country.

Key words: administrative-territorial division, historiography, statistics, positivism, historical geography, regional studies, new imperial history, imperial administration, state reforms.

Author:

Ashikhmin, Andrey Vitalievich — researcher fellow at the Center for Advanced Scientific
Research of the Russian National Library, Chief Specialist of the Department of Scientific Publications of the Russian State Historical Archive (St. Petersburg, Russia).
E-mail: andrew_ashikhmin@mail.ru
ORCID: 0000-0002-9830-3565

References:
Biktasheva, A. N. Antropologiya vlasti: kazanskie gubernatory pervoi poloviny XIX veka [Anthropology of Power: Kazan Governors of the First Half of the 19th Century. In Russ.]. Moscow, Novyi khronograf publ., 2012, 496 p.

Efimova, V. V. General-gubernatory Evropeiskogo Severa: mesto i rol’ v sisteme organov gosudarstvennoi vlasti i upravleniya Rossiiskoi imperii (1820–1830 gg.) [Governors-General of the European North: Place and Role in the System of State Authorities and Administration of the Russian Empire (1820–1830). In Russ.]. St. Petersburg, Dmitrii Bulanin publ., 2019. 832 p.

Manakov, A. G. Izmenenie administrativno-territorial’nogo deleniya na Severo-Zapade Rossii v imperskuyu epokhu [Changes in the Administrative-Territorial Division of Northwest Russia During the Imperial Era. In Russ.]. In Arktika XXI vek. Gumanitarnye nauki. 2015. No. 3 (6), pp. 4–20.

Matkhanova, N. P. Vysshaya administratsiya Vostochnoi Sibiri v seredine XIX v.: problemy sotsial’noi stratifikatsii [The Supreme Administration of Eastern Siberia in the Mid‑20th Century: Problems of Social Stratification. In Russ.]. Novosibirsk, Sibirskii khronograf publ., 2002, 250 p.

Moryakova, O. V. Sistema mestnogo upravleniya Rossii pri Nikolae I [The System of Local Government in Russia under Nicholas I. In Russ.]. Moscow, Moscow State University press, 1998, 272 p.

Poberezhnikov, I. V. Frontirnaya modernizatsiya na Vostoke Rossiiskoi imperii: regional’nye variatsii [Frontier Modernization in the East of the Russian Empire: Regional Variations. In Russ.]. In Ural’skii istoricheskii vestnik. 2018. No. 4 (61), pp. 72–80.

Razdorskii, A. I. Bibliograficheskie resursy Rossiiskoi natsional’noi biblioteki istochnikov kraevedcheskoi informatsii o regionakh Rossiiskoi imperii XIX — nachala XX v. [Bibliographic Resources of the Russian National Library of Sources of Local History Information about the Regions of the Russian Empire of the 19th — early 20th Century. In Russ.]. In Zhurnal instituta naslediya. 2023. No. 3 (34), pp. 1–10.

Redin, D. A. Sibirskaya landratura: mesto vyatskikh landratov v strukture gubernskogo upravleniya perioda pervoi oblastnoi reformy Petra Velikogo [Siberian Landratura: The Place of the Vyatka Landrats in the Structure of Provincial Administration during the First Regional Reform of Peter the Great. In Russ.]. In Izvestiya Ural’skogo federal’nogo universiteta. Ser. 2: Gumanitarnye nauki. 2012. No. 3 (105), pp. 31–47.

Remnev, A. V. Sibir’ v imperskoi geografii vlasti XIX — nachala XX vekov [Siberia in the Imperial Geography of Power of the 19th — early 20th Centuries. In Russ.]. Omsk, Omsk State University press, 2015, 577 p.

Tarkhov, S. A. Istoricheskaya evolyutsiya administrativno-territorial’nogo i politicheskogo deleniya
Rossii [Historical Evolution of the Administrative-Territorial and Political Division of Russia. In Russ.]. In Regionalizatsiya v razvitii Rossii: geograficheskie protsessy i problemy. Moscow, URSS publ., 2001, pp. 190–213.

Tikhonov, V. V. Moskovskaya istoricheskaya shkola v pervoi polovine XX veka: nauchnoe tvorchestvo Yu. V. Got’e, S. B. Veselovskogo, A. I. Yakovleva, S. V. Bakhrushina [Moscow Historical School in the First Half of the 20th Century: Scientific Work of Yu. V. Gautier, S. V. Veselovsky, A. I. Yakovlev, S. V. Bakhrushin. In Russ.]. St. Petersburg, Nestor-Istoriya publ., 2012, 320 p.

Zubkov, K. I. Frontir kak issledovatel’skaya paradigma [Frontier as a Research Paradigm. In Russ.].
In Ural’skii istoricheskii vestnik. 2018. No. 4 (61), pp. 63–71.

Similar Posts

PHJ № 1 (49) 2026 — G. I. Bayazitova, F. E. A. Giral. LETTER FROM CARDINAL DE RICHELIEU TO THE FRENCH AMBASSADOR TO SWITZERLAND, BRULARD DE LEON (APRIL 9, 1630)

The article is devoted to the study of a manuscript letter by Cardinal de Richelieu, First Minister to King Louis XIII of France, who managed the internal and foreign policy of France from 1624 to 1642. The autograph of Richelieu is kept in the Russian National Library in St. Petersburg as part of the Dubrovsky Collection. Although it was already known to M. Avenel, the first editor of Cardinal de Richelieu’s correspondence, it had not yet been introduced to the scholarly community. Also, a transcription of the letter without commentary or translation is contained in the latest monograph by A. D. Lyublinskaya. The letter dates back to the War of the Mantuan Succession and is addressed to de Leon, French ambassador in Switzerland. The letter concerns Marshal de Bassompierre’s role in the negotiations with the Cantons of Switzerland. The introductory article provides the context for the document’s appearance, reconstructs the series of events that preceded its creation based on historical sources, and draws a conclusion about the message’s place in Cardinal Richelieu’s correspondence. The article provides a transcription, translation, annotated commentary, and a reproduction of the original letter. The publication of this autograph adds to the research on 17th-century French documents located in Russia, initiated by A. Lyublinskaya, and advances ourunderstanding of Cardinal de Richelieu’s activities.

|

PHJ № 2 (50) 2026 — L. V. Klimovich. HISTORIAN NIKOLAI IVANOVICH ULYANOV — LIFE AS AN “ADVENTURE NOVEL”. BOOK REVIEW: BAZANOV P. N. PROTECTION OF THE UNITY OF RUSSIA: THE LIFE AND WORK OF HISTORIAN NIKOLAI ULYANOV. ST. PETERSBURG: ROSTOCK PUBL., 2025. 688 P.

The reviewed book is a documentary investigation of the biography of Nikolai Ivanovich Ulyanov, a prominent representative of the Russian emigration of the second wave, a historian, cultural critic, and public figure. Drawing upon a plethora of unpublished sources, the eminent specialist in the history of the Russian diaspora, P. N. Bazanov, chronicles the life of his subject, who was born in the Russian Empire, was apprehended and incarcerated in the USSR, twice escaped from German captivity, was abducted by the Nazis to work in Germany, was designated a “displaced person”, and subsequently became a prominent researcher on the history of Russia, issues of state integrity, and problems of Ukrainian separatism. The review concludes that the book has indisputable advantages, namely reliability, maximum objectivity, consistency, correctness of presentation and conclusions drawn from a wide range of sources and research literature.

PHJ № 1 (49) 2026 — A. V. Chirkova. DOCUMENTS OF THE DOGES OF VENICE FROM THE 14TH TO THE FIRST HALF OF THE 16TH CENTURY COLLECTED BY NIKOLAY P. LIKHACHEV: ON THE HISTORY OF THE COLLECTION

In the West European Section of the Archive of the St. Petersburg Institute of History, Russian Academy of Sciences, there are 64 original charters from Venetian doges dating from the 14th to the first half of the 16th century: 18 sentences (ducali maggiori) and 46 letters (ducali minori). They originate from the collection of Academician N. P. Likhachev and were purchased for his Museum of Palaeography, where the history of writing was represented from the turn of the 3rd–4th millennium BC, primarily through documentary monuments. The documents were acquired between 1892 and 1914 at European auctions and through correspondence with other collectors. Thanks to Likhachev’s annotations on the covers of the charters, it is possible to establish the time and place of acquisition for 20 documents: private collections of Gabriele Fantoni (4) and Alexander Posonyi (2, by the Friedrich Cohn auction), auctions of Pio Luzzetti (7), Tammaro De Marinis (3), Gabriel Charavay (1), Sotheby’s (1), “Gilhofer und Ranschburg” (2). Through the analysis of owners’ inscriptions on the covers and on the charters themselves, the provenance of the documents is traced back to the collections of Gian Carlo Rossi (10), Luigi Azzolini (2), presumably Luigi Arrigoni and Amilcare Ancona (1), and two unattributed collectors (4 and 2). The analysis of the provenance shows that before being accumulated in Likhachev’s collection, these ancient acts changed hands multiple times.

|

PHJ № 2 (50) 2026 — P. V. Krylov. REVIEW OF A MONOGRAPH WITH PUBLICATION OF SOURCES: TOKAREVA E. S. THE VATICAN IN THE FOCUS OF SOVIET POLICY AND PROPAGANDA. 1921–1941. MOSCOW, VES’ MIR PUBL., 2023. 784 P.

The present review examines the book by E. S. Tokareva, which is dedicated to the relations between the Holy See and Soviet Russia in 1921–1941, with the publication of relevant documents. The book elucidates the modus operandi of the Republic of Soviets’ non-public diplomacy towards the Roman Catholic Church in the context of overcoming the diplomatic blockade of the USSR by the leading world powers.

|

PHJ № 2 (50) 2026 — M. A. Averyanov, A. B. Gekht. THE CRISIS OF THE FRENCH COLONIAL SYSTEM: THE EMERGENCE AND ACTIVITIES OF THE OAS

This article examines the phenomenon of the Secret Armed Organisation (OAS), a farright terrorist group that emerged in the early 1960s amidst the collapse of the French colonial empire and Algeria’s struggle for independence. The paper explores the historical circumstances leading up to the organisation’s creation and the underlying motivations of those who joined its ranks. The publication provides a comprehensive overview of the OAS’ historical development, delineating its fundamental objectives and the violent means employed to realise them. Moreover, the study examines the societal response to the movement and the underlying factors that led to its eventual failure. It also acknowledges the substantial historical legacy bequeathed to both France and Algeria by the movement, in addition to its influence on popular culture. Acknowledging the dearth of scholarly attention this topic has received in Russian historiography, the research aims to fill this academic gap, emphasising the modern relevance of understanding the French Fifth Republic’s political experience with colonial wars.

|

PHJ № 2 (50) 2026 — I. I. Barinov. “I BEG YOU TO DO SOMETHING TO AVERT THE TROUBLES…”. LETTERS FROM EDGAR AMMENDE TO HIS BROTHER EWALD AMMENDE (1921)

The publication unveils hitherto unpublished correspondence between the Estonian public figure Ewald Ammende (1892–1936) and his brother, the merchant Edgar Ammende (1894–1978), who was imprisoned by the Cheka in Moscow. The published documents provide illuminating insights into the diplomatic tensions that characterised the initial establishment of Soviet-Estonian relations during the period 1920–1921. Moreover, they offer a comprehensive perspective on the intricacies of the revolutionary era that characterised the early years of Soviet rule in Russia.