DOI 10.51255/2311–603X_2025_3_75

A. B. Astashov. Economic Abuses and Combating Them in the Russian Theater of Military Operations during the First World War // Petersburg Historical Journal, no 3, 2025, pp. 75–85

Abstract:

The article is devoted to a rare topic — the analysis of economic crimes in the Russian theater
of military operations during the First World War. In Russian historiography the question of abuses is more often considered from the point of view of class position or politicized approach to the activities of public organizations — All-Russian unions of zemstvos and cities. In this paper, written on the basis of archival materials, the emphasis is on the identification of economic crimes in the conditions of frontline everyday life, their types, dynamics, increasing volumes of economic losses, and their impact on the socio-political situation in the country. Particular attention is paid to the activities of public organizations and the attitude of the authorities and the army to them. The central subject is the fight against economic crimes by the army, especially in the Petrograd Military District. The author comes to the conclusion about the mass of problems in the organization of the supply of the population, the contradictory coexistence of two new types of war: regulation and free market is revealed. The war exposed the shortcomings of the system of supplying the army with the help of a group of persons (Jews) whom the authorities did not trust, and at the same time could not do without them. Hidden machinations, which were part of the daily routine of warfare, caused great harm to defense: speculation, mass fabrication of documents for property. The inconsistency of waging war “for money” was aggravated by the lack of reliable control, the absence of an effective legal framework, and the clash of interests of the military and civilian administration, as well as the agents of the free market. This combination of contradictory factors led to great losses of resources, suffering of millions of citizens, damage to the cause of defense, and the threat of loss of statehood. In this situation, sporadic, haphazard attempts by military figures to combat economic crime by neutralizing individual criminals, even of the highest level, were doomed to failure.

Key words: army supply, economic crimes, military field control, ethnocriminalistics, All-Russian Zemsky and City Unions, Northern Front, Petrograd Military District, regulatory.

Author:

Astashov, Alexander Borisovich — Dr. of Sci. in History, Professor, Russian State University for the Humanities (Moscow, Russia).
E-mail: astashsh@yandex.ru
ORCID: 0000-0002-2651-964X

References:

Ayrapetov, O. R. Generaly, liberaly i predprinimateli [Generals, Liberals, and Entrepreneurs. In Russ.]. Moscow, Tri kvadrata, 2003. 256 p.

Brandes, S. D. Warhogs: A History of War Profits in America. Lexington, The University Press of Kentucky, 1997. 384 p.

Gaida, F. A. Vlast’ i obshchestvennost’ v Rossii: dialog o puti politicheskogo razvitiya (1910–1917) [Power and Public in Russia: Dialogue on the Path of Political Development (1910–1917). In Russ.]. Moscow, Russkii fond sodeistviya obrazovaniyu i nauke, 2016. 604 p.

Khutarev-Garnishevskii, V. V. Protivostoyanie. Spetssluzhby, armiya i vlast’ nakanune padeniya Rossiiskoi imperii, 1913–1917 gg. [Confrontation. Special Services, Army and Power on the Eve of the Fall of the Russian Empire, 1913–1917. In Russ.]. Moscow, Izdatel’stvo Instituta Gaidara, 2020. 648 p.

Kitanina, T. M. Voina, khleb i revolyutsiya (prodovol’stvennyi vopros v Rossii. 1914 — oktyabr’ 1917-go) [War, Bread and Revolution (The Food Question in Russia. 1914 — October 1917). In Russ.]. Leningrad, Nauka, 1985. 384 p.

Kulikov, S. V. Finansovye aspekty deyatel’nosti rossiiskikh blagotvoritel’nykh organizatsii voennogo vremeni (iyul’ 1914 — fevral’ 1917 g.) [Financial Aspects of the Activity of Russian Charitable Organizations in Wartime (July 1914 — February 1917). In Russ.]. In Bulgakova, L. A. (ed.). Blagotvoritelnost v istorii Rossii: Novye dokumenty i issledovaniya. Saint Petersburg, Nestor-Istoriya, 2008. P. 369–396.

Laverychev, V. Ya. Voennyi gosudarstvenno-monopolisticheskii kapitalizm v Rossii [Military State-
Monopolistic Capitalism in Russia. In Russ.]. Moscow, Nauka, 1988. 335 p.

Tonkii, N. V. Organizatsiya i funktsionirovanie tylovogo obespecheniya russkoi armii v nachale XX veka: 1900–1917 gg. [Organization and Functioning of Logistics of the Russian Army in the Early 20th Century: 1900–1917. In Russ.]: dis. … kand. ist. nauk. Voronezh, 2012. 256 p.

Vasilev, I. I., Zdanovich, A. A. General N. S. Batyushin. Portret v inter’ere russkoi razvedki i kontrrazvedki [General N. S. Batiushin. Portrait in the Interior of Russian Intelligence and Counterintelligence. In Russ.]. In N. S. Batyushin. U istokov russkoi kontrrazvedki: sbornik dokumentov i materialov. Moscow, Kuchkovo pole, 2007. P. 1–14.

    Перейти к полноэкранному режиму

    Similar Posts

    PHJ № 2 (46) 2025 — M. N. Baryshnikov. BATUM IN THE OPERATIONS OF THE RUSSIAN STEAM NAVIGATION AND TRADING COMPANY (1874–1913)

    The article, which is based on documents from the Russian State Historical Archive, examinesthe main directions of operations of the Russian Steam Navigation and Trading Company in the port of Batum between 1874 and 1913. The data sources were used to address three research questions. Firstly, what were the regional directions and content (cargo and passenger transportation) of these shipping operations? Secondly, the importance of these operations in terms of the regional needs of Batum was investigated. Thirdly, the investigation sought to ascertain whether these operations exerted a substantial influence on coastal and international shipping. The methodological framework utilised facilitated the identification of key stages,institutional agreements between stakeholders (public-private partnerships) and goods movements within supply chains, and the nature of trade relationships between regions. It also illuminated how corresponding change and development is shaped by consumer demand, geopolitical and socio-economic situation, and, naturally, the functioning of maritime transport. The findings reveal that these changes and developments are driven by several factors: favourable infrastructural conditions in the port of Batum; location-specific advantages such as the ability to coordinate domestic and foreign transportation and effectively redirect cargoand passengers; and governmental negotiations processes as a result of the shipping company’s strong position, peculiarities of the multinational character and Black Sea region’s economic capabilities.

    PHJ № 2 (46) 2025 — I. V. Zykin. THE CONSEQUENCES OF THE WINTER WAR OF 1939–1940 FOR THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE SOVIET PULP AND PAPER INDUSTRY

    One of the tasks of industrialisation in the Soviet Union in the late 1920s and early 1940s was the development of the pulp and paper industry due to low production volumes and dependence on imported equipment and technologies. Despite the establishment of joint ventures, research institutes, and machine-building enterprises, it was not possible to overcome the quantitative and technological lag behind the countries of Europe and North America — the leaders of the pulp and paper industry. The article analyses the potential of pulp and paper enterprises on the Karelian isthmus at the turn of the 1930s and 1940s and the consequences of the Soviet-Finnish War for the pulp and paper industry of the USSR. At the end of the 19 th century — in the 1930s, a large complex for the deep processing of wood was built on the Karelian isthmus. Advanced technologies were used in the production of pulp and cardboard, which were not available in the Soviet Union. However, Soviet specialists paid little attention to Finland’s experience, preferring Germany, Sweden and the USA, where, in addition to technology, mechanical engineering was being developed. The accession of the Karelian isthmus to the Soviet Union after the Winter War of 1939–1940 became an important factor in the development of the pulp and paper industry. The work carried out between April 1940 and May 1941 showed the importance of coordinating the efforts of party-state, planning and economic bodies, concentrating human and technological potential in the restoration of enterprises and the development of their capacities, maintaining dependence on energy imports, control and measuring equipment for pulp cooking and the return of evacuated equipment. An advanced complex for deep processing of wood appeared in the Soviet Union, which significantly changed the spatial and technological development of the pulp and paper industry. The beginning of the Great Patriotic War, Finland’s attack on the side of Germany led to the evacuation of enterprises and the temporary loss of territories.

    | |

    PHJ № 3 (47) 2025 — S. G. Nelipovich. THE ROMANIAN CAMPAIGN: COMBAT LOSSES (SEPTEMBER 1916 — JANUARY 1917)

    The combat losses of the opposing armies are indicative not only of the casualties and the intensity of the fighting, but also a factor in assessing the combat effectiveness of the troops. The article, which is based on documents from the State Military Historical Archive of Bulgaria (DVIA), the Russian State Military Historical Archive (RGVIA), the Austrian State Archive (ÖStA), the Bavarian Main State Archive (BayHSA), and information collected by researchers from different countries, identifies and clarifies the losses of the armies of Bulgaria, Romania, Austria-Hungary, the German, Ottoman and Russian Empires during the Romanian campaign (September 1916 — January 1917). The substantial losses sustained by the Romanian army in Transylvania, particularly in Dobrudzha, were a contributing factor to the defeat of the Romanian forces in the autumn and winter of 1916. This ultimately resulted in the loss of Wallachia and Bucharest. Researchers have not yet reached a consensus on the precise figure for the size of the losses suffered by the Romanian army, which is estimated to be between 300 thousand and 500 thousand men. The losses sustained by the Russian armies of the Romanian Front are documented for the first time (totalling up to 262 thousand men). The losses sustained by the armed forces of the Quadruple Alliance during the Romanian campaign of 1916 were significant, with a total of 167,000 casualties recorded. This was primarily attributable to the intensity of the hostilities. The Bulgarian army suffered significant losses, with estimates reaching up to 55,000 casualties.

    PHJ № 3 (35) 2022 – A. B. Gekht. Under the scrutiny of criticism: financial and industrial group of the Wallenberg family and public sentiment in Sweden in the 1960s

    This article is devoted to the consideration of the diverse public rhetoric in the 1960s towards Sweden’s largest financial and industrial group controlled by the Wallenberg family. A discussion about the nature of Wallenberg’s activities outside the kingdom, primarily in the developing countries of Latin America and Africa, became especially noticeable. Among the consequences of the harsh criticism of the Wallenbergs was the subsequent strengthening of government regulatory measures in the Swedish economy in the late 1960s, which affected the financial sector, which was so important for the financial and industrial group under their control.